Monthly Archives: December 2024

The Rose Garden, Chapter 20 – Progress

File:Golden Christmas Tree Ornament.jpg

Christmas tree ornament, Author Noah Wulf, (CC BY-SA 4.0 International)

For I know the thoughts that I think toward you, says the Lord, thoughts of peace and not of evil, to give you a future and a hope” (Jer. 29: 11).

I decide I want to put a tree up this year, after all.  One by one, I pull the boxes out of the closet.  Joni Mitchell sings about skating away on a river, as I gently lift the ornaments from their places.  This one with Ziggy on it is twenty-five years old.  How rapidly our lives rush by.  Here are Snoopy and the rest of the Peanuts gang.  Here are the Looney Tunes characters — Porky Pig, Tweety Bird, Bugs Bunny.

Angels, rocking horses, pipers, drummers, partridges and their kin, Santas (both lean and stout), reindeer, shepherds, teddy bears.  They crowd one upon another, each a memory, some bittersweet.

I used to dread going to my parents’ for the holidays.  The thought of pretending we were a cheerful, trouble-free family, in the same room where my father had so often molested me, would make me want to retch.  Christmas, Easter, birthdays, no excuse could justify an absence.

We would sit at the dining room table, my father in his underwear, my mother hurrying to and fro with the plates, despite repeated offers of assistance.  My father would dismember the turkey, portions enormous, notwithstanding, our protests about diet.

Without fail, at some point during dinner my father would look over at me and remark in a bemused tone, “I just can’t see you as a lawyer, Annie.”  Without fail, at some point he would make a racial comment.  On schedule, an argument would follow.

My sister and I would hurry upstairs soon after dinner, as far away from Ma and Dad as possible.  Back at my apartment after the visit, I would empty my suitcase into the hamper, strip off my clothes, then shower to remove any remaining taint.

My sister’s husband, a kind and decent man, helped change the dynamic.  Not that he was easily accepted into the family.  When they first announced their engagement, there was dead silence at the table.

Both my mother and father grew to love their son-in-law.  My father genuinely admired his skills at carpentry and household repairs.  Pop enjoyed talking with him about sports, history, and — surprisingly enough — the “old country.”

Conversation at the dinner table expanded to cover these topics.  Tensions eased. Continue reading

15 Comments

Filed under Child Abuse, Child Molestation, Christianity, Emotional Abuse, Neglect, Physical Abuse, Religion, Sexual Abuse

The Rose Garden, Chapter 19 – In the Wilderness

File:Employment Law Office.jpg
Law office boardroom, Source https://www.htwlaw.ca, Author Tony Wong (Free Use)

“Behold, I will do a new thing, Now it shall spring forth; Shall you not know it?  I will even make a road in the wilderness And rivers in the desert ” (Isa. 43: 19).

Kite flying was something I did not do well as a child.  Still, I tried every summer to make a successful kite, one that would soar overhead.

I was aware that kites could be purchased at the local five and dime, but did not think to ask for one.  It was clear such frivolities were beyond the family’s means.  Instead, I constructed my kites of the materials at hand:  loose-leaf paper and cardboard, bakery string, and rags.

The kites did rise briefly, but never very high, resolutely though I ran with them down the hill in front of our house.   I dreamed occasionally, myself, of flying — capable in dreams of rising effortlessly off the ground, like a bird, whenever I wished.

I was not very adept at sledding either.  Snow did not fall often enough in the Bronx to allow much opportunity for practice, and the hill in front of our house was not particularly steep.  I did not view these conditions as bearing on my sledding abilities.  Despite them, I persisted.

Emotional Transparency

The situation was much the same at the first legal firm at which I worked.  This was a medical malpractice firm.  I had not heard of malpractice before; knew only that I wanted litigation.  Suddenly, the biology major I had pursued made sense.

My first firm specialized in brain-damaged infant cases. These are among the most serious and difficult, with large monetary value.  Because of that, trials in this specialty are hard for a young attorney to come by.  One of the first principles driven home to me was that the attorney’s ego must be secondary to the clients’ good.

Trial work here was the Holy Grail, the measure of an attorney, but always something mysterious, as well. As young attorneys, we jockeyed over the few available trial opportunities.  Little by little, we acquired the necessary skills.

I, however, made a fundamental mistake.  I let my feelings of insecurity show at the office.

Fear is a natural component of trial work.  Those who have done it for any length will confirm this.  We carry the responsibility of the clients’ welfare.  The full force of risk falls upon us.

We have high rates of alcoholism and substance abuse; are prone to depression; die of heart failure and stroke, sometimes in the courtroom.

We are an irreverent bunch.  Some of this is due to the fact our jobs require us to push the envelope.  Some of it is a reaction to the stress — a response that, as children, my sister and I used to call “laughing in the face of death.”

Unfortunately, my emotional transparency (a consequence of boundary violation) was viewed as a vulnerability.  No matter how hard I worked, I was passed over.

As young attorneys, we often had to request the rescheduling of trial dates by the courts.  We joked that our cards should read, impressively, “Adjournments in All Courts.”

With litigation as common as it is in this country, court calendars are heavy.  Judges are impatient to move cases along.  Adjournments were not always easy to secure.

On one particular occasion, I was instructed by the Office Manager to obtain a short adjournment on a case already marked “final.”  On the way to court, I had an accident on the parkway.

It was a rainy day.  Traffic was heavy, but moving.  A vehicle entering from the right caused the driver ahead of me to stop suddenly.  I slammed on the brakes in order to avoid a collision, and went into a spin on the wet pavement.

Time seemed to stand still.  A huge truck came into view.  I closed my eyes and gripped the wheel, anticipating impact.  Expecting to die.

Instead, my vehicle came to a soft stop.  I opened my eyes to find I had spun 180 degrees and was facing the vehicle originally behind mine, our bumpers barely touching.

None of us in the vehicles involved had been injured.  The police took a report, but we decided as a group to go on with the day.  As far as I know, no litigation ever resulted.

My concern at that moment was getting to court on time.  I got back in my car, drove the rest of way, and managed to get the necessary adjournment.

To my dismay, the Managing Partner was unhappy with my efforts.  Though my inadvertent mentor, he accused me of having manipulated the situation, so that no other attorneys would be available on the adjourned date, and I could try the case.

I was stunned.  Thankfully, I could point to the Office Manager’s written instructions.

I never mentioned the accident.  There seemed no point.

Things reached such a level of frustration for me at the firm that I found myself crying in the office bathroom one day.  As I sat on the edge of the tub, it suddenly dawned on me that I deserved better.  I dried my tears, walked out, and gave notice. Continue reading

15 Comments

Filed under Child Abuse, Child Molestation, Christianity, Emotional Abuse, Law, Neglect, Physical Abuse, Rape, Religion, Sexual Abuse

The Rose Garden, Chapter 18 – Love and Loss

File:Venice Carnival - Masked Lovers (2010).jpg

Venice Carnival – Masked Lovers, Source https://flickr.com, Author Frank Kovalchek, Anchorage, AK, (Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic)

WARNING:  Graphic Images

He heals the brokenhearted And binds up their wounds” (Ps. 147: 3).

The hotel clock reads 4:30 AM.  I can see from the bed that it is still dark outside.  Unable to sleep, unable to bear the thought of spending another day in Los Angeles, I pick up the phone and reschedule my flight. 

That done, I move around the room, gathering and throwing things carelessly into my bag.  I walk over to the closet, stare briefly at the blue silk dress I had hoped to wear on Mulholland Drive, but decide to leave to it behind.  

Downstairs in the rental car, I head on unfamiliar freeways to the airport.  The trip is a blur.  I veer sharply to the right, across two lanes, to make my exit.  Horns blare. 

Once on the plane, I stare blindly forward.  My chest heaving, I begin to sob.

I have been fortunate in both male and female friends, but have loved three men deeply in my life.  Whether lanky, wiry, or muscular, all three were men of integrity and high intelligence.  All three were incapable of commitment, at least to me.

All three were lawyers, heaven help me.

How does the heart choose?  We seek out what we have known, try as we may not to do this.  The choice (unconscious though it may be) is an attempt to correct for past mistakes, to erase the scars.

I sought out emotionally elusive men — men unable to love me.  As a result, love caused me far more grief than joy.  What kept me in the relationships was not that these men loved me, but that they might.  I was familiar — in a sense comfortable —  with being loved only marginally.

The other characteristics I selected for were kindness and a history of suffering.  I wanted to ease pain, but justified behavior toward myself other women would not have tolerated.  I never considered whether I deserved a healthy and fulfilling relationship.

Both sexual abuse and codependence played a role in this.

I settled for little, believing I deserved less.  In fact, I did not see myself as deserving of love at all.  I simply assumed a normal, stable man would reject me; would be unable either to understand or put up with my pain.

My hope, my unspoken prayer, was that someone capable of kindness and with his own knowledge of loss might be better equipped.

It was to such men I was drawn.  One lost his father early to serious illness.  Another suffered at the hands of a cold and critical mother.  The last was abandoned by his father following divorce.

The problem with my approach was that I sought out men as wounded as myself.  Though not worth any less, those deeply wounded early in life may find it difficult to love or be loved.

There is too much risk involved in revealing the true self.  Instead, they repeat unhealthy patterns, and inflict damage of their own.

Certainly I did.  As an example, at a college concert my sister had looked forward to attending with me, I opted to sit near the object of my affection and his date, rather than with my sister.  That verges on masochism.  Yet, had he told me he loved me, my own love would likely have evaporated.

My sister remained steadfast.  I remember standing in the front hall, nervously checking my reflection before heading out for the evening.  “You look beautiful,” my sister said.  “If he doesn’t love you, he’s an idiot.”

Though I cannot say with any certainty, I suspect now that two of the men I loved may, themselves, have been victims of emotional or covert incest.

Fear of intimacy can be well-founded.  Those of us who suffer from it seek out difficult or impossible relationships.  Normalcy is perceived as boring; intimacy, as suffocation.

The goal of healing the beloved can become the justification for our existence.  Paradoxically, the beloved is chosen for his or her inability to heal.  It is the resulting tension that constitutes the real glue of the relationship.

“You have a wonderfully feminine quality.” “I love your body.  It’s so responsive.” “Any man in his right mind would want you.”  All lies men tell women.  All lies I have cherished.

When our relationship ended, I packed and shipped for safekeeping to a friend the emails one man and I had exchanged.  Though the dream had died, I could not bear to part entirely with the words. Continue reading

23 Comments

Filed under Child Abuse, Child Molestation, Christianity, Emotional Abuse, Justice, Neglect, Physical Abuse, Religion, Sexual Abuse

The Rose Garden, Chapter 17 – Illness

File:MarkhamStouffvilleHospital23.jpg

Emergency Room, Markham Stouffville Hospital, Ontario, Author Raysonho @ Open Grid Scheduler/Grid Engine, (CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication)

“…rejoicing in hope, patient in tribulation, continuing steadfastly in prayer…” (Rom. 12: 12).

There may be an abuse-related dimension common to all the major illnesses from which I have suffered over the years, disparate though at first they appear.

The mechanism of this is not fully understood, but is thought to involve somatization, i.e. the expression of psychological or emotional factors as physical symptoms [1].  The pain associated with somatization is a physiologic response to the stress and trauma of abuse, but all too real [2].

Abuse and Autoimmune Disease

Around the age of twelve, I suffered a major attack of hives.  Though I did not know it then, this presaged the chronic urticaria (CU) from which I suffer today.  In effect, the body does not recognize, and so attacks itself.

A growing body of research suggests a link between childhood abuse and the development of autoimmune disease [3].

At the time of the initial hives, I was repeatedly bathed in ice water as I writhed.  Since they had been on the phone to a physician, it was twenty-four hours before my mother or grandmother considered taking me to an emergency room.

Of course, my mother had gone to work with a second degree sunburn.  Her enormous blisters burst while she was on the subway.  My grandmother washed the kitchen floor on her hands and knees the day after she returned home from the hospital, following a hysterectomy.

After years of childhood earaches and tonsillitis, I finally had my tonsils removed at age nineteen.  Following surgery, I awoke from anesthesia to find my father at the foot of the hospital bed.  I cannot convey the joy I felt.  It was entirely unexpected and moved me immensely that he had taken time off from work to see me.

It strikes me as funny to this day that I shared a room with a Jehovah’s Witness and a Black Muslim.  Unable to speak, I lay there between them as my fellow patients held theological arguments at high volume across my bed.

Abuse and Endometriosis

From the time I first began to menstruate, my periods were irregular and accompanied by severe cramps.  Endometriosis was ultimately diagnosed.  Child abuse has, also, been linked to endometriosis [4].

It would not be until my thirties that I obtained any relief.  Before that, each month I would swallow as many aspirin as I could tolerate, then lie prostrate on the bathroom floor, comforted by the cool tile until the pain passed.

Again, no one took me to an emergency room.  I remember the pain ending early one Christmas morning, after I had endured it for some ten days.  Julia Child was on TV at the time, demonstrating how to stuff a turkey.  I have retained a sentimental fondness for her ever since.

The day I took the scholarship exam for college, my period came on suddenly during lunch.  We had completed the morning session and were sitting in the cafeteria.

With the onset of cramps and bleeding, I rushed to the ladies room, but could find no sanitary napkins.  Desperate, I attempted unsuccessfully to insert my first tampon, all the while doubled over in pain.

Wave after wave of cramps rolled over me.  I broke out in a sweat.  For some reason, after forty minutes, the cramps stopped on their own.  I used toilet tissue to craft a make-shift pad, and rejoined the others in time to sit for the afternoon session.

I won a full scholarship, as a consequence.  With no thought to a career, I chose biology as my major out of wonder at the beauty of the world.  Medicine — since I tend to faint at the sight of blood — was never an option.

Years later, I, too, had a hysterectomy.  I had to be taken from my office by stretcher — moaning, but issuing last minute instructions to the staff as I went.

My then Office Manager, a close friend, stayed by my side.  This was no surprise.  We had done the office budget together one weekend, as her infant daughter lay asleep in a carrier on the floor at our feet.

Abuse and Chronic Back Pain

I have had many years of back pain.  A fall may have aggravated the scoliosis from which I suffer.  It, also, produced disc herniation.  But childhood trauma is frequently associated with chronic neck or back pain [5].

At times the pain has been so severe I have wondered if it would kill me.  Ultimately, I had to undergo a spinal fusion at the cervical level, then spend three months strapped into a brace.

The procedure necessitated a bone graft from my right hip.  The night before surgery, the nurse and I laughed together as we wrote on my left side in black marker, “Wrong Hip.”

Groggy from pre-anesthesia medication and fearful that a tube could damage my vocal chords, my last words to the anesthesiologist before surgery were, “Please, be careful.  I’m a lawyer.”  He undoubtedly thought I was issuing a threat.

I did not let my mother (who was seriously ill, herself, at the time) know about my surgery until it was over.

While I recuperated, a long-time friend, arranged to have meals sent to my home.  Another close friend drove me upstate to her summer place.
Continue reading

25 Comments

Filed under Child Abuse, Child Molestation, Christianity, Emotional Abuse, Neglect, Physical Abuse, Religion, Sexual Abuse

The Rose Garden, Chapter 16 – The Weight of Sorrow

File:Clothing Rack of Jeans.jpg

Clothing rack of women’s jeans, Source https://www.publicdomainpictures.net, Author Peter Griffin, (CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication)

Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of God” (Matt. 4: 4).

It is late in the season.  I wander from one clothing rack to another, searching for my size.  The coats have been picked through.  There are few remaining.  It is unlikely I will be able to find a coat that fits, let alone flatters, me.

Please, God, I pray.  Please, let me find something.  I promise to lose weight.  I promise to try harder.

One scar of the incest has been of such magnitude in my life that it warrants separate discussion.  This is weight control.  I have prayed as fervently in the Women’s Department as in any cathedral.

For an abuse victim, the difference between size 8 and size 18 is no mere matter of discipline.  A child who is molested feels like offal.  Whatever impulses drive her abuser, she is less than nothing in his eyes, and — despite his soothing words to the contrary — she knows it.

Against this backdrop, weight often becomes a problem.  Eating disorders are common — anorexia, bulimia, binge eating, etc. [1][2][3][4].  In this, I am typical.

Distress, Defense, Punishment, and Shame

Food is a natural source of comfort for the sexually abused child, maladaptive when weight becomes an issue.

Weight serves many purposes.  It is a distress signal:  silent evidence of the molestation, the secret exposed.  It is a defense, the child’s feeble attempt to create a physical barrier against the predator; later, an emotional barrier to adult relationships.

Increased weight is a psychological way of hiding from rejection.  Failed relationships can be blamed on weight.  However painful this approach may be, it is less painful than rejection of the “true self.”

Weight is punishment for misplaced guilt.  The little girl cannot be forgiven for having engendered the violation (as if she did), and cannot forgive herself for being “unlovable.”  So her anger turns inward, with depression the result.

The cycle repeats itself — over and over — as weight is gained, lost, and regained.   In the process, weight becomes an alternate focus for the shame of the abuse.

All this is unconscious.

A Symbol of Rage and A Test

As the child grows into a woman, weight takes on even more shades of meaning.  It embodies rage at men; shouts, in effect, “Damn them all!  They’re vapid and shallow, anyway — unable to recognize real worth.”

It serves as a test for the woman.  It serves as a test for the man she hopes will love her.  It serves as punishment for the woman’s failure to be lovable, yet again.

Food as Love – An Analgesic and An Anesthetic

Food offers instant gratification while love, in her experience, does not.

Food is, of course, nourishment.  As the body requires food, so the soul requires love.  Love is vital.  The soul craves it.  Deprived of love, the soul starves.  Food becomes the unsatisfactory substitute for love denied, an analgesic against the pain.

In terms of our anger at having been abused, food is more like an anesthetic.  Unable to express that anger appropriately at the time, we forced it down with food, then “forgot” why we were eating (or denying ourselves food) so compulsively.  Attempts to diet are futile because they do not address the underlying rage.

Distrust of God

While we may not think in such terms, at a deeper level, a disordered relationship with food by abuse victims reflects a distrust of God.

Since our needs were not met as children by those who stood in God’s shoes, we have little reason to believe that God will meet them now.  So we try to meet them ourselves, try to assure that we will at least have as much (or little) food as we want.

But we cannot satisfy our hunger — our desire not only for love and justice, but for control over our own lives — since that hunger is emotional rather than physical.

God is capable of filling our needs.  However, we must first put our trust in Him.  For abuse victims, that can be a lifelong challenge.

All this applied to me; took me decades to decipher.  Continue reading

16 Comments

Filed under Child Abuse, Child Molestation, Christianity, Emotional Abuse, Neglect, Physical Abuse, Religion, Sexual Abuse